James Fetzer and the Pozner v. Fetzer court ruling
This page is about James Fetzer and the Sandy Hook lawsuit Leonard Pozner filed against him in Wisconsin. It says who Fetzer is in that case, what the court decided, and where to read the original filings on this site.
Key Takeaways
- James Fetzer is a defendant in Pozner v. Fetzer, Dane County Case No. 2018CV003122.
- On June 18, 2019, the court ruled that he defamed Leonard Pozner by publishing statements that Noah Pozner’s death certificate was fake.
- A jury awarded $450,000. The amended judgment is $1,107,395.13. A permanent injunction bars four of the statements.
- The Wisconsin Court of Appeals affirmed the ruling on March 18, 2021.
Who James Fetzer is
James Fetzer is a defendant in Pozner v. Fetzer, a defamation case in the Circuit Court for Dane County, Wisconsin (Case No. 2018CV003122). Court papers and news coverage collected on this site describe him as a retired professor living in Wisconsin. With Mike Palecek, he helped produce the 2016 book Nobody Died at Sandy Hook, subtitled “It Was a FEMA Drill to Promote Gun Control.”
The book claimed the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut, never took place. The Wisconsin Court of Appeals later described Fetzer’s position this way: that the shooting was an “elaborate hoax,” that no one was killed, and that part of that false claim was the invention of a “fiction[al]” child named Noah Pozner. Those claims are false. Noah Pozner was six years old. He was killed on December 14, 2012, with 19 other children and six educators.
To show that Noah lived and died, Leonard Pozner posted a certified copy of Noah’s death certificate online. Fetzer then published statements about that document. In the 2016 book he wrote: “Noah Pozner’s death certificate is a fake, which we have proven on a dozen or more grounds.” He also called it a “forgery” and a “fabrication.” In an August 5, 2018, blog post, he repeated the fabrication claim and said the document combined “the bottom half of a real death certificate and the top half of a fake.”
What the court ruled
In 2018, Leonard Pozner sued Fetzer, Palecek, and others for defamation in Dane County. On June 18, 2019, the court granted Pozner’s motion for summary judgment. It held that Fetzer and Palecek defamed Pozner by publishing those statements about Noah’s death certificate. The court denied Fetzer’s own motion and left the amount of damages for a jury.
In October 2019, a Dane County jury awarded Pozner $450,000. On December 17, 2019, the court entered a permanent injunction (Document 354) that bars Fetzer from repeating four of the statements, by any means. An Amended Judgment filed July 27, 2020 (Document 443) awards Pozner $1,107,395.13: the $450,000 jury award, $650,000 in attorneys’ fees ordered by the court and agreed to by the parties, and $7,395.13 in fees and costs.
Fetzer appealed. On March 18, 2021, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals affirmed the ruling (Appeal Nos. 2020AP121 and 2020AP1570). Later filings on this site cover enforcement, contempt, and a sanctions order under Wisconsin Statute § 802.05. For a dated list of news and HONR articles, see the Pozner v. Fetzer timeline. For a plain-English account of why the Sandy Hook hoax claims are false, see why the Sandy Hook hoax claims are false.
Court records
- Order granting summary judgment (June 18, 2019)
- Permanent injunction (December 17, 2019, Document 354)
- Amended Judgment (July 27, 2020, Document 443) — $1,107,395.13
- Court of Appeals decision (March 18, 2021)
- Sanctions order under Wis. Stat. § 802.05
- All documents, including orders, motions, pleadings, and transcripts
Official case docket: WCCA Dane County 2018CV003122.
Frequently asked questions
Who is James Fetzer?
He is a defendant in Pozner v. Fetzer, Dane County Case No. 2018CV003122. He helped produce the 2016 book Nobody Died at Sandy Hook, which claimed Noah Pozner’s death certificate was fake. A Wisconsin court later ruled that those statements were defamation.
What did the court rule about James Fetzer?
On June 18, 2019, the court granted summary judgment, holding that Fetzer and Mike Palecek defamed Leonard Pozner by publishing statements that Noah Pozner’s death certificate was fake.
How much is the judgment against James Fetzer?
The Amended Judgment filed July 27, 2020 (Document 443) totals $1,107,395.13, including a $450,000 jury award, $650,000 in attorneys’ fees, and $7,395.13 in fees and costs.
Is James Fetzer barred from repeating the statements?
Yes. A permanent injunction entered December 17, 2019 (Document 354) bars him from repeating four statements the court had already found defamatory. The Court of Appeals later left that ruling in place.
Where can I read the court documents?
The filings are posted on this site. Start with the Documents page, or use the court-records list above.